Should You Buy From a Captive Agent or an Independent Agent? 2023

Did you know that there are different kinds of life and health agents? The differences lie in the type of company your agent represents and their pay structures, but these factors end up resulting in the type of insurance you buy, whether it's the best product for your needs or not.

Imagine a shoe store that only sells even number sizes. Unfortunately, you wear a size 9. The salesperson, who may or may not be honest, will try to tell you that they have something "close enough" for what you need. You try on the shoes and they are either too big or too small. The salesperson is limited in what he or she can sell, so they are going to try to get you to purchase what they have on hand.

In the insurance world, we have captive and independent agents. Captive agents typically are contracted to work with one company (unless that company has an agreement with another carrier) and are not allowed to shop around with other carriers. Typically, these are companies that carry your home and auto, but not always.

Why would an agent want to be captive? One reason is that you only need to learn one set of products, so you don't get spread too thin. Also, the company will normally provide supplies, office space and other perks, like training meetings and coaching. Sometimes they will even offer a salary or a draw for the first few months. This is great for a new agent trying to get their feet wet in the business. The downside is that the commissions are lower. A lot lower.

On the other hand, an independent agent works on their own, paying for their own overhead and making larger commissions. But the offerings to the client are much more expansive, as these agents can shop around literally hundreds of companies to find the "shoe" that fits the clients precise needs.

I knew a couple of agents years ago that ran a captive office. They loved to talk trash about whole life insurance, mainly because their company didn't carry it. I'm not a huge fan of whole life, but there are times when it fits the bill, so I make sure I have a couple of good carriers at my disposal when I need it. These two didn't have that luxury, as they only sold term and universal life. 

Don't get me wrong, some of my favorite people do well as captive agents. And when I show them what I can offer my clients they usually look surprised. Few of them offer indexed universal life, so when I explain to them how it works I get mixed reactions, from slight envy ("I wish we offered that") to outrage ("This is obviously a horrible product or we would sell it!").

An older agent once summed it up as follows. "Captive agents work for a company that can fire them. Independent agents work for the client and can fire the company if they don't treat the client well."

As you can see, we at Surf Financial Brokers are independent agents. We don't have a sales manager whispering in our ears about hitting sales quotas or any obligation to any of our carriers. Simply put,we enjoy having he resources to get the right size shoe on the foot in a comfortable and affordable way.

Stay healthy and let us know if you need anything.

Chris Castanes is the president of Surf Financial Brokers, as well as a professional speaker helping sales people be more productive and efficient.

How Your Disability Insurance Can Help You Now Part 1

As we are in the midst of the Coronavirus pandemic I thought now was a good time to post a bit on Disability Income insurance (DI). As the name implies, DI insures your income. And that income pays your bills.

Ask yourself what your biggest asset is. Is it your home, your car or the money in your bank account? Actually, none of those is correct for the vast number of Americans. Your number one asset is your ability to earn a living. And if you are sick or hurt and can't work, what happens to the bills? They just keep coming.

If you have a group DI plan through work, that's fantastic! Most of these are voluntary, so if you enrolled in a plan, you may be paying for it through deductions from your paycheck. Sometimes, the employer pays for it. And sometimes, there's a mix of the two. For example, you may be paying for a short term policy that covers you for 3 or 6 months, and the employer pays for the long term plan that begins after the short term plan stops paying benefits.

Be aware that your benefits are typically tax free with two exceptions. If your company is paying for the coverage or if you've decided to pre-tax your premium. A good insurance agent will discourage the latter. If you're out of work due to a sickness or injury, and you go on claim, you'll be getting about 65% of your salary, only to have it taxed. Ouch!

Many business owners, self-employed and contract employees aren't eligible for a DI plan through work. For those people, individual DI plans are available. They may be structured differently but generally do the same thing, which is protect your income. However, you may be subject to underwriting.

And speaking of underwriting, know that your health AND your income are going to be looked at. Smoking, your age and other factors, including pre-existing conditions will be considered. Many times the insurance carrier will ask for your medical records. And they may want to take a look at your recent tax returns. Since the benefit is based off of your income, they want to make sure you earn what you say you earn. Makes sense.

Another factor is your occupation. The safer your job is the less expensive the rate. A welder or a roofer will be charged more than the person who sits in a cubicle. And some occupations are difficult to insure (or aren't considered). Take professional athletes, for example. I tried to insure a young lady a few years ago who was a professional golfer on a smaller circuit. No company would even consider her.

In the next post, we'll discuss elimination periods other items to consider when purchasing a DI plan. In the meantime, stay healthy and of course let us know if we can help answer your questions.

Chris Castanes is the president of Surf Financial Brokers, as well as a professional speaker helping sales people be more productive and efficient. 

Do You Have Any Insurance That Covers Coronavirus?

Lately a lot of people have me, as well as the rest of the insurance industry, if there are any policies that cover the Covid-19 or Coronavirus. The answer is of course, yes. We can quickly cover a few:

• Major medical - As with all ailments, your major medical has few exceptions, and the virus is not one of them. As usual, you'll still on the hook for co-pays and deductibles, but that is insignificant if you're in the hospital for a few days or longer.
• Hospital Indemnity - Speaking of hospital stays, a hospital indemnity (HI) plan is usually offered through work, but Surf Financial Brokers has started carrying an HI plan that can be offered on an individual basis. 
• Disability Income - A traditional DI plan will cover you and your paycheck if you are out of work due to the virus, or any other illness. There may be an elimination period (the time before your benefits actually begin) of between 0-30 days, so check your policy. 
• Life insurance - If you have life insurance and die from the Coronavirus, your beneficiaries shouldn't have to worry about the company not paying the claim. First of all, legally the carrier has to pay under the terms of the policy, which is a legal contract. Secondly, it would be a public relations nightmare if the insurance company arbitrarily decided to not pay. 

Any or all of the above policies should pay a claim if you were to get sick from the Covid-19 virus, but be aware that the life, HI and DI plans may pre-existing conditions exclusions. In other words, don't expect to get a policy issued if you just had the virus.

For a list of policies offered by Surf Financial Brokers, click here. Some even have interesting videos.

Most importantly, please stay well, healthy and practice social distancing as much as possible.



Chris Castanes is the president of Surf Financial Brokers, as well as a professional speaker helping sales people be more productive and efficient. 

The Differing Types of Life Insurance Pt 4 (The Universal Life Talk)

We covered, in broad strokes, term and whole life policies in my previous posts and we're getting to the end of this series. (Yes, life insurance is one of the most of exciting topics and I'm sure you're going to be sad when this is over.)

Finally we have one of the most confusing products of all time, Universal Life (UL). Less expensive than whole life but with the ability to build cash, UL is a good fit for some clients. The "engine" that built cash values on traditional UL's for years was interest rates. Back in the 1970's and 1980's when interest rates were high, many agents who should have known better, sold UL's as investment vehicles. Years later, when interest rates dropped dramatically, the cash values inside those policies were being overtaken by the "cost of insurance", which rises as years go by. Basically, the policy will eat away at itself if the interest rate isn't high enough.

And to make up for the shortages, the premiums on your policy may increase. I met a gentleman who had taken out a policy in the early 1980's and since then his premiums had increased to nearly $300/month. On top of this his health had taken a turn for the worse over the years, with diabetes and heart issues now in the picture. He would have a very difficult time finding a new policy and was forced to keep the one he had.

I worked in an insurance office in the early 2000's and the owner threatened to fire anyone selling a UL. She was on the receiving end of angry clients who wanted to take a few hundred dollars out of their policies and it wasn't there. These policies had been in effect for years and there was nothing to show for it.

The insurance companies woke up to the dismal sales (no agent wants his head bitten off so they didn't talk to the clients about them) and devised a way to resurrect the UL. They took the "index" from an indexed annuity and used it to replace the interest rate. The Indexed Universal Life (IUL) was born!

In the life insurance community there has been debate for years on whether or not the IUL's are as good as they seem. The ones who don't like them are typically agents who have been selling whole life policies and see these policies as a threat to their income (see part 1 in this series). I worked for a very large life insurance carrier who forbade us from selling anything indexed and threatened us with termination.

The key to making an IUL work well is how it's structured. Assuring that it's funded properly will make all the difference in the world and can help down the road as a retirement supplement. And many top carriers of IUL's include riders like living benefits and critical illness at no charge. This means you can use your policy while you're alive, if need be.

A few years ago Patrick Kelly wrote a book titled "The Retirement Miracle" in which he explains how an IUL is a great savings tool for our later years. The video quality isn't that great but here goes..



Finally, as I mentioned in the previous post, the better alternative to a final expense policy (which is usually a whole life plan) is a Guaranteed Universal Life (GUL) policy. A GUL is like a traditional UL except it builds minimal cash value. However, it's guaranteed to stay the same price, like a whole life, until your passing. The obvious question is why would you want cash value in a final expense plan? You wouldn't. The premiums are much lower but be aware that the GUL is typically underwritten like any other life insurance policy, so if you're healthy, you would be doing better when it comes to price.

Hopefully, you'll have a better understanding of what each kind of policy can do and make a wise choice when purchasing protection, not for yourself, but for your loved ones. I realize that this is a lot of information so if you have any questions leave them in the comments section below. And stay healthy!

Chris Castanes is the president of Surf Financial Brokers, as well as a professional speaker helping sales people be more productive and efficient. 

What Is Final Expense Insurance?

We've all seen the commercials on TV with Alex Trebek telling senior citizens that they can cover the cost of a funeral with a life insurance policy.  But what kind of insurance is it and how much will it cost?

Usually, final expense coverage is a whole life policy, which is the most expensive type of life insurance because it builds some cash value.  But do you really care about building cash value to pay for a funeral?  Probably not.  The main concern is covering the cost of a funeral  while making sure your premium doesn't increase.

In the case of our friend, Mr. Trebek, he says that you can't be turned down.  That's a good thing if you are in poor health, but being "guaranteed issue" also means that the additional risk to the company is being passed on in the cost.  Generally speaking, "guaranteed issue" costs more.

If you are in good health, there is a better and more affordable alternative.  Guaranteed Universal Life (GUL) typically runs about a third less and the rate is also guaranteed to never go up as long as you pay your premiums.  The GUL may ask for a paramed exam to qualify buy this lowers the carrier's risk, which in turn lowers your price. 

If you're looking for a way to cover the expenses of a funeral, let us help.  Contact Surf Financial Brokers for information. 

The Agents' Problems With Health #Insurance

As we all know, health insurance changed dramatically in this country several years ago with the ACA or Obamacare rules.  Instead of individual policies with various deductibles, companies were forced to offer policies with "essential health benefits" or ESB's, which meant that all policies had to offer certain coverages.  This, as well as forcing carriers to cover people with pre-existing conditions, drove rates through the roof.

But how did it all affect your health insurance agent?  

First, the law mandated that 70% of premiums had to go toward claims.  This left 30% to go toward administrative costs, overhead, salaries and, yes, commissions.  Those commissions shriveled up like a Sunsweet raisin.  I don't sell based on commission only, however, this is my job, not a hobby.  I need to make a living as well.  Obamacare created several new outlets for people to get their coverage, including a website, an 800 number and navigators, which are non-insurance licensed enrollers.  People don't need an agent.

Secondly, we have a short window of time, the open enrollment period, to enroll you.  Outside of that time period, we can enroll if you have a special situation, ie you lost coverage through your job or you got married.  But the companies have decided NOT to pay commissions on those sales.  Again, it's not a hobby.

Finally, the agents we talk to are generally disgusted with the whole process and don't want to keep investing their time and energy getting certified each year while not knowing if our politicians are going to repeal, replace, tweak, fund or defund the system.  

With all of this in mind, we at Surf Financial Brokers have made the decision to stop offering health insurance until conditions get much better.  However, we are taking the time to make sure we offer the best options when it comes to Medicare Supplements, life insurance and group benefits (minus health) for our clients.  

Please let us know if we can assist you!